Thank you for writing. When talking to Israeli defenders they always seem to suggest that non-binding advice from the ICJ has no weight whatsoever. They use this to then justify Israel's ongoing existence and occupation of the OPTs as not violating international law. I think this argument comes from the barrister Natasha Hausdorff (UK Lawyers for Israel). She has popularised this argument I think. Do you have any advice on how best to counter it? Thanks again.
Thank you for your thoughtful comment and for engaging so closely with the piece. It is a question many people run into, and you are right to take it seriously.
The claim that ICJ advisory opinions are "non-binding" is technically true but badly misleading. Advisory opinions do not create enforceable obligations the way a binding judgment between two states does. But they are authoritative statements of what international law already requires, delivered by the principal judicial organ of the United Nations. That is why they set the legal standards and framework that UN bodies, national courts, and national and international human rights organizations rely on in their work. The opinion does not make the law; it clarifies it. Treating it as optional advice confuses the status of the instrument with the status of the rules it confirms, which bind states regardless.
On the substance, it is well established that Israel's presence has gone far beyond what the law of occupation contemplates. Under the Fourth Geneva Convention and its protocols, occupation is meant to be a temporary, exceptional situation, with the occupying power acting as a caretaker and not a sovereign. A decades-long occupation, coupled with settlement building and annexation in practice, is the opposite of that. The ICJ's 2004 and 2024 opinions both reached this conclusion, and so one cannot cite the occupation's longevity as proof of its legality.
I would also gently suggest that the best counter to this argument is to widen the frame. Palestine is not merely a legal question. It is a political, ethical, and colonial question. When defenders retreat into narrow procedural points, such as whether an opinion is binding, they are often trying to keep the conversation inside a technical space where the underlying reality disappears. Naming it as a colonial question brings it back into view.
Finally, international law itself needs to be rethought in light of how much the world has changed. The old fantasy of great powers governing the rest of the world's peoples through the Security Council, with vetoes that shield allies from accountability, is racist and unjust in its own right. A legal order that cannot enforce its own standards against the powerful will keep producing exactly this kind of argument.
Thank you for your response Hiba. That is most helpful. I had forgotten about the supposed temporary nature of occupation in the Geneva Convention.
Yes the issue of vetoes makes a mockery of the current system and I hope that is done away with soon. It's such a western, colonial notion it's embarrassing it still exists.
I subscribed and look forward to reading more. Thanks again.
Thank you for writing. When talking to Israeli defenders they always seem to suggest that non-binding advice from the ICJ has no weight whatsoever. They use this to then justify Israel's ongoing existence and occupation of the OPTs as not violating international law. I think this argument comes from the barrister Natasha Hausdorff (UK Lawyers for Israel). She has popularised this argument I think. Do you have any advice on how best to counter it? Thanks again.
Thank you for your thoughtful comment and for engaging so closely with the piece. It is a question many people run into, and you are right to take it seriously.
The claim that ICJ advisory opinions are "non-binding" is technically true but badly misleading. Advisory opinions do not create enforceable obligations the way a binding judgment between two states does. But they are authoritative statements of what international law already requires, delivered by the principal judicial organ of the United Nations. That is why they set the legal standards and framework that UN bodies, national courts, and national and international human rights organizations rely on in their work. The opinion does not make the law; it clarifies it. Treating it as optional advice confuses the status of the instrument with the status of the rules it confirms, which bind states regardless.
On the substance, it is well established that Israel's presence has gone far beyond what the law of occupation contemplates. Under the Fourth Geneva Convention and its protocols, occupation is meant to be a temporary, exceptional situation, with the occupying power acting as a caretaker and not a sovereign. A decades-long occupation, coupled with settlement building and annexation in practice, is the opposite of that. The ICJ's 2004 and 2024 opinions both reached this conclusion, and so one cannot cite the occupation's longevity as proof of its legality.
I would also gently suggest that the best counter to this argument is to widen the frame. Palestine is not merely a legal question. It is a political, ethical, and colonial question. When defenders retreat into narrow procedural points, such as whether an opinion is binding, they are often trying to keep the conversation inside a technical space where the underlying reality disappears. Naming it as a colonial question brings it back into view.
Finally, international law itself needs to be rethought in light of how much the world has changed. The old fantasy of great powers governing the rest of the world's peoples through the Security Council, with vetoes that shield allies from accountability, is racist and unjust in its own right. A legal order that cannot enforce its own standards against the powerful will keep producing exactly this kind of argument.
Thank you again for reading and for asking.
Warm regards,
Hiba
Thank you for your response Hiba. That is most helpful. I had forgotten about the supposed temporary nature of occupation in the Geneva Convention.
Yes the issue of vetoes makes a mockery of the current system and I hope that is done away with soon. It's such a western, colonial notion it's embarrassing it still exists.
I subscribed and look forward to reading more. Thanks again.